Maximising Economic Recovery
A New Approach to Regulating the UK's Offshore Oil and Gas Industry
Judith Aldersey, Valerie Allan
Published: 2023
Pages: 296
eBook: 9781787429727
The title describes the regulatory tools at the NSTA’s disposal including the nature of the OGA Strategy and how this can be enforced through sanctions, the right to attend a wide range of industry meetings, request vast amounts of industry data and to get involved in industry disputes.
This was intended to address the problems of an ageing basin in which smaller discoveries meant new fields were more marginal and interdependent than in the past. An increasingly diverse set of companies operating these smaller, more interconnected fields resulted in greater competition for ageing infrastructure and required increased collaboration between operators to ensure that fields remain economical. These factors, coupled with growing competition for investment from outside the UK, had led to significant falls in production, production efficiency and exploration.
The new approach requires regulated persons active in UKCS operations to seek to maximise economic recovery not just from their own assets but across the basin and therefore requires unprecedented levels of collaboration. It has also resulted in a far more hands-on regulator seeking to use both influence and enforcement to radically alter the culture of the UKCS.
This book is not a complete guide to oil and gas industry regulation in the UK; instead, it is specific to the MER UK regime. It describes the legislative changes that introduced the regime, the nature of the NSTA, and how it uses ‘soft power’ to achieve many of its aims. It also describes the regulatory tools at the NSTA’s disposal including the nature of the OGA Strategy and how this can be enforced through sanctions, the right to attend a wide range of industry meetings, request vast amounts of industry data and to get involved in industry disputes. It also discusses the increasing focus of the NSTA on the energy transition.
This book will be of interest to legal practitioners active in energy law whether in private practice or in house, academics and students with an interest in energy regulation and regulators looking at the UKCS as a model for other jurisdictions.
Table of Contents
Cover | Cover | |
---|---|---|
Title | 1 | |
Copyright | 2 | |
Table of Contents | 3 | |
Foreword | 7 | |
1. Introduction | 11 | |
2. Background | 13 | |
1. The Wood Review process | 13 | |
2. Overview of MER UK | 20 | |
3. How the OGA works | 27 | |
1. The nature of the OGA | 27 | |
2. Relationship to government | 28 | |
3. Transfer of statutory powers to the OGA | 33 | |
4. Directions by the Secretary of State | 34 | |
5. Review of OGA’s performance by the Secretary of State | 34 | |
6. Funding | 35 | |
7. Power and discretion | 39 | |
8. Culture | 40 | |
9. Structure | 44 | |
4. The OGA Strategy | 47 | |
1. Background | 47 | |
2. The principles | 48 | |
3. The central obligation (paragraph 2 of the OGA Strategy) | 50 | |
4. Supporting obligations | 55 | |
5. Required actions | 66 | |
6. Safeguards | 69 | |
7. Relationship between MER UK and contracts | 74 | |
5. The OGA as influencer | 77 | |
1. Overview | 77 | |
2. Commissioning of seismic acquisition and other research | 78 | |
3. Publication of data | 81 | |
4. National Data Repository (NDR) | 84 | |
5. Energy Pathfinder | 87 | |
6. Analysis and publication of one-off reports | 87 | |
7. Benchmarking and setting of KPIs | 88 | |
8. Promotion of best practice | 94 | |
9. Engagement with industry | 99 | |
10. Cultural change | 102 | |
6. Asset stewardship | 105 | |
1. Asset stewardship in the Wood Report | 105 | |
2. Asset stewardship obligation | 107 | |
3. Asset Stewardship Strategy | 108 | |
4. Asset Stewardship Expectations and guidance | 112 | |
5. What is the status of the Asset Stewardship Expectations? | 116 | |
6. Asset Stewardship Survey | 116 | |
7. Tiered Stewardship Reviews | 118 | |
8. Area Plans | 121 | |
9. Supply Chain Action Plans | 125 | |
7. Meetings | 129 | |
1. Introduction | 129 | |
2. Relevant meetings | 129 | |
3. The OGA’s powers in relation to relevant meetings | 130 | |
4. Provision of information regarding meetings | 130 | |
5. Meetings Statutory Notice | 132 | |
6. Thematic review | 136 | |
8. Non-binding dispute resolution | 137 | |
1. Introduction | 137 | |
2. Overview of the OGA’s powers in respect of disputes | 137 | |
3. Power to gather information | 139 | |
4. The OGA’s Dispute Resolution Guidance | 143 | |
5. The process | 144 | |
6. Process where reference accepted | 153 | |
7. Recommendations | 156 | |
8. Examples in practice | 157 | |
9. Appeals | 158 | |
9. Information and samples | 159 | |
1. Background | 159 | |
2. Overview of the 2016 Act provisions | 160 | |
3. Information and samples plans (ISPs) | 162 | |
4. ISP Guidance | 164 | |
5. Information and samples coordinator (ISC) | 165 | |
6. ISC Guidance | 166 | |
7. Retention of information and samples | 167 | |
8. Reporting | 170 | |
9. Disclosure by OGA | 174 | |
10. Measured escalation and investigation | 181 | |
1. Background | 181 | |
2. The OGA’s general approach | 182 | |
3. Facilitation/enhanced facilitation | 184 | |
4. Enquiries (prior to November 2022) | 185 | |
5. Initial Assessment (post-November 2022) | 193 | |
6. Investigations | 196 | |
7. Mediation Pilot | 202 | |
11. Sanctions | 207 | |
1. Sanctions in the context of the OGA’s activities | 207 | |
2. Circumstances where sanctions may be imposed | 207 | |
3. Sanction Warning Notices | 209 | |
4. Sanction Notices generally | 210 | |
5. Types of sanctions | 211 | |
6. Enforcement Notice | 212 | |
7. Financial Penalty Notice | 213 | |
8. Revocation Notice | 217 | |
9. Operator Removal Notice | 217 | |
10. Withdrawal of Sanction Notice | 218 | |
11. Appeals in relation to Sanction Notice | 218 | |
12. Publication of Sanction Notice | 220 | |
13. Sanctions in practice | 221 | |
12. MER UK and energy transition | 223 | |
1. Background | 223 | |
2. The UK and energy transition | 225 | |
3. The OGA and energy transition: policy development | 227 | |
4. The OGA and energy transition: key actions | 232 | |
5. The OGA and energy transition: next steps | 242 | |
13. OGA and third-party access | 245 | |
1. Overview | 245 | |
2. Third-party access in the OGA Strategy | 246 | |
3. MER UK and ICoP | 246 | |
4. OGA powers to set terms of access | 247 | |
5. Applications under the Energy Act 2011 | 254 | |
14. MER UK and competition law | 257 | |
1. Overview of UK competition law | 257 | |
2. Guidance on information exchange | 258 | |
3. Collaboration on the UKCS | 258 | |
4. The role of the CMA in the development of MER | 260 | |
5. The OGA Guidance | 263 | |
6. Application of competition rules to MER UK | 264 | |
7. Potential solutions to competition law issues | 266 | |
15. Decommissioning | 269 | |
1. Decommissioning in the Wood Report | 269 | |
2. Responsibility for regulating decommissioning | 270 | |
3. Changes to the Petroleum Act 1998 in relation to decommissioning | 271 | |
4. The OGA Strategy and decommissioning | 273 | |
5. OGA Guidance | 274 | |
6. Decommissioning and Repurposing Taskforce | 275 | |
7. Cost reduction | 276 | |
8. Decommissioning microsite | 278 | |
9. Decommissioning Data Visibility Project | 278 | |
Glossary | 279 | |
Index | 283 | |
About the authors | 293 | |
About Globe Law and Business | 295 |
MER is a complicated concept, made all the more complex by recent amendments to the strategy. The intrinsic value of this book is its deep dive into the origins of MER, the changes that have occurred, and the recent shift in name and strategy to the broader energy transition. Trying to piece all of the components of MER is difficult, but this book makes it much easier. This is an exceptional book from exceptionally knowledgeable authors. This book is timely given the importance of MER in the UK's energy transition strategy.
Professor Tina Soliman Hunter
Professor of Energy and Resources Law, Macquarie University
The work is an outstanding feat of synthesis and fresh analysis. It will be an indispensable reference point for all that is subsequently written on this topic. It is essential reading for all practitioners involved in the UK offshore oil and gas industry.
Professor Greg Gordon
University of Aberdeen
Judith Aldersey-Williams
Of counsel, CMS
[email protected]
https://www.linkedin.com/in/judithalderseywilliams/
Judith Aldersey-Williams is part of the CMS Energy & Climate Change Team, based in the Aberdeen office but working internationally, with over 20 years of experience in upstream oil and gas contracts and regulation. She advises energy industry clients on project and supply chain contracts and regulatory matters. She also advises on competition and procurement law. Judith has worked closely with Offshore Energies UK, the trade association representing the offshore energy industry, on a variety of industry initiatives including the industry standard Decommissioning Security Agreement (DSA) and Joint Operating Agreement (JOA).
Her career highpoints have been advising Offshore Energies UK on the development of Decommissioning Relief Deeds, ground-breaking contracts by which the UK government guarantees tax relief for decommissioning, and advising the Subsea Well Response Project, a group of nine multinational oil companies, on contracts for the development and funding of innovative equipment which is now available to enable operators around the world to improve their response to well control incidents. She is rated a “Leading Individual for Oil & Gas in Scotland” by Legal500 who describe her as “a go-to for regulatory, antitrust and commercial contract matters” and as a “Senior Statesperson” by Chambers for Oil & Gas in Scotland.
See website biography for more details: https://cms.law/en/gbr/people/judith-alderseywilliams.
Valerie Allan
Partner, CMS
[email protected]
https://www.linkedin.com/in/valerieallan/
Valerie Allan is an energy disputes partner, based in Scotland but with a practice that extends across the UK and overseas. She specialises in dispute management and resolution in the energy, construction and infrastructure sectors. Valerie has particular expertise in project, joint venture and decommissioning disputes. She is also recognised for her expertise in respect of regulatory issues regarding the Oil & Gas Authority and in supporting clients navigating the growing number and intensity of protestor actions directed at oil companies and their assets.
Valerie is an Acritas-Star rated lawyer and recommended by clients there specifically for her industry knowledge and understanding. She is recognised as a key lawyer for Oil & Gas in Scotland in Legal500 and ranked Band 3 in Chambers for Energy & Natural Resources Disputes (UK-wide). She is a trained mediator and the senior DPLP tutor on mediation for Aberdeen University. She is primarily responsible for CMS’s annual oil & gas disputes survey and regularly presents and contributes to various publications.
See website biography for more details: https://cms.law/en/gbr/people/valerie-allan.